TL;DR: Guest Posting Is Just Link Buying with Extra Steps
Guest posting today often equates to paying for editorial links dressed up as legitimate content, a practice that may boost SEO short-term but poses risks like Google penalties.
• Agencies profit heavily by reselling placements on low-traffic sites.
• ROI from paid guest posts is declining due to abuse.
• Ethical guest blogging prioritizes relationships and high-quality content over link exchanges.
Startups should focus on sustainable strategies, like writing optimized content, targeting niche audiences, and leveraging real collaborations. Want actionable tips? Check out guest blogging on high-DA niche sites for authentic authority-building opportunities: Proven Benefits & Tips.
Check out startup news that you might like:
Why does having insights across multiple LLMs matter for brand visibility?
I’ve asked this question more times than I can count: “Is guest posting just a glorified way to buy links?” And trust me, it’s a question that comes with layers of controversy, especially in the SEO and startup world. Not as an outside observer, but as someone who has spent over two decades building businesses, some bootstrapped, some scaling with unconventional strategies, this debate is deeply personal to me because it impacts how we think about marketing, ethics, and growth.
When I was scaling my deeptech startup, CADChain, I had countless offers from agencies peddling “premium” guest posts. Big promises, bigger prices, and every pitch framed it as a legitimate SEO tactic guaranteed to deliver ROI. For a bootstrapped founder, $500 for a single article on some barely recognizable website wasn’t just expensive, it was outright predatory. Every dollar I spent mattered, which made the idea of buying these marketed “content placements” feel borderline unethical and completely removed from how businesses should authentically grow.
Here’s my take: Guest posting in its current form is just link buying with extra steps. You’re essentially paying for “editorial links,” dressing it up with a nice bow of content to make it look like something it isn’t. Don’t take my word for it, Google itself reiterates in their guidelines that paying for links, whether explicitly or as an “exchange,” goes against policy. Yet, the industry continues perpetuating its use under the guise of legitimacy.
Does Guest Posting Really Work?
Let’s get one thing straight: The entire premise of guest posting hinges on backlinks. If you strip away the glamorous pitches from SEO agencies, what remains? A transactional exchange of value, whether it’s money, content, or exposure, for a followed link. Take out the link and very few would even consider doing it. The unfortunate truth? It still works in the short-term. It can push rankings, bring in organic traffic, and sometimes even improve domain authority. But at what cost, and for how long?
Take one of my founder friends as an example. She spent upwards of $15,000 on guest posting services over eight months. Yes, she saw an initial uplift in traffic, until Google’s SpamBrain algorithm flagged many of her backlinks. The result? Traffic tanked, rankings plummeted, and the worst part? All that money was wasted. What remained was frustration and a hard-earned lesson about how unethical shortcuts rarely sustain themselves in this game.
- Google continues to crack down on all forms of obvious link schemes, guest posting included.
- Most “guest post opportunities” come from low-authority sites with inflated Domain Rankings.
- There’s a diminishing ROI the more widely this technique is abused across industries.
The takeaway? Guest posting might seem like an appealing “hack,” but it’s increasingly becoming a liability for startups rather than a sustainable strategy.
Who Actually Benefits From Paid Guest Posts?
If you think about it, the real winners of paid guest posting aren’t the businesses buying the links, it’s the middlemen selling them. Outreach agencies and SEO firms have built entire industries based around these transactions, dressing up link selling as “building relationships” or “content placement opportunities.” For smaller brands and bootstrapped businesses, this approach often feels like walking straight into a trap.
Here’s how the guest post supply chain typically works:
- An agency pays a website owner to accept posts (essentially a bribe for backlinks).
- The agency marks up that cost considerably before reselling it to businesses as a “premium placement.”
- Businesses shell out hundreds, sometimes thousands, of dollars for each post.
The worst part? Many of these sites have little to no actual traffic or authority. Sure, they pass on link juice, but they rarely drive meaningful engagement or leads. It’s little more than a glorified game of pretending to appease search algorithms.
In this scenario, small businesses are at a massive disadvantage. The entire structure punishes those who don’t have enormous budgets to throw at SEO tricks. And honestly? It’s a heavy criticism I have of the industry as someone who believes in bootstrapped entrepreneurship.
Is There an Ethical Way to Approach Guest Posting?
Yes, and it starts by revisiting the purpose of guest posting in the first place. Rather than chasing backlinks, focus on building real relationships and delivering genuine value through your content. Here’s how:
- Target niche, relevant audiences: Find blogs or platforms that actually align with your startup’s goals. If your audience spends time there, it’s worth the effort, even without a backlink.
- Collaborate instead of paying: Offer true value through collaborations. Share data, insights, or resources instead of cash.
- Focus on expertise: Position yourself as an expert contributor rather than just a guest looking for exposure. Prioritize high-quality, compelling content over squeezed-in backlinks.
At Fe/male Switch, for example, we collaborate with fellow gamepreneur educators in our niche. Instead of pay-to-play posts, we host joint webinars, exchange assets, and cross-promote through social channels. These activities generate real trust, authentic backlinks, and, most importantly, true community value.
Why Founders Need a Better Strategy
Guest posting as link buying is a shortcut that simply doesn’t hold up. Founders, especially bootstrapped ones, can’t afford strategies that might implode after the next algorithm update. Building a business is hard enough without having to worry about gambling your SEO budget on shady approaches.
Here’s what I tell fellow female founders in our startup community:
- Invest in evergreen SEO skills, learn to create high-value, search-optimized content yourself or hire someone proficient.
- Leverage no-code and AI tools to streamline content production while maintaining a personalized touch.
- Skip the agencies and do diligent outreach yourself. Build a database of reputable, traffic-heavy blogs, then pitch creative article ideas.
The truth is, this approach takes longer. It’s far from glamorous. But it delivers long-lasting, authentic results. And if you’re a bootstrapping founder, playing the long game is almost always the smarter choice.
Final thought: Guest posting isn’t “dead,” but the way most agencies sell it to startups is. Stop thinking of it as an SEO hack and start treating it as an opportunity to create something meaningful. As the industry (thankfully) evolves, founders who prioritize authenticity will always be a Google update ahead of the curve. So ask yourself: Do you want flimsy link juice or a reputation you can build on? Choose wisely. Your startup depends on it.
People Also Ask:
What is meant by guest posting?
Guest posting refers to the practice of writing and publishing content on another person's or company's website. It is typically done to build relationships, gain exposure, establish authority, and earn backlinks to your own site.
Is guest posting real or fake?
Guest posting is a real and legitimate strategy in digital marketing. However, misuse of this tactic for manipulative link-building practices can make it appear fake or unethical. Genuine guest posting focuses on high-quality content and meaningful audience engagement.
What is link insertion in guest posting?
Link insertion involves adding a backlink into an existing article on a host website, whereas guest posting includes writing a fresh, high-quality article for another site. Both methods aim to improve link-building strategies, but their execution differs.
How to do guest posting step by step?
To ensure effective guest posting:
- Research target websites.
- Review guest post guidelines.
- Pitch clear and personalized ideas.
- Create unique, high-quality content tailored to the host audience.
- Include a relevant backlink in the article or bio.
What are the pros and cons of guest posting?
Pros:
- Increases brand visibility.
- Builds backlinks for SEO growth.
- Strengthens authority in your niche.
Cons:
- Time-intensive content creation.
- Risk of being perceived as manipulative if poorly executed.
How effective is guest posting for SEO?
Guest posting can benefit SEO when done correctly with high-quality content and relevant backlinks. It improves domain authority, drives organic traffic, and boosts visibility on search engines.
Is paid guest posting a good strategy?
Paid guest posting can be effective for gaining backlinks and reaching new audiences, but it must comply with search engine policies to avoid penalties associated with manipulative link schemes.
How can you identify scammy guest posting requests?
Look for signs such as generic outreach emails, poor-quality content, irrelevant pitches, or an emphasis on paid links. These can indicate questionable practices that may not align with genuine guest posting goals.
What are the differences between guest posts and niche edits?
Guest posts require creating new articles for publication, while niche edits involve adding links to existing articles. Guest posts offer more customization, whereas niche edits are faster but rely on pre-existing content.
What are the common mistakes in guest posting?
Common mistakes include:
- Using AI-generated or plagiarized content.
- Targeting low-quality websites for publications.
- Overloading articles with irrelevant backlinks.
- Neglecting the host site's guidelines or audience preferences.
FAQ on Guest Posting and SEO Strategies
How can startups avoid wasting budget on low-ROI guest posting?
Startups can avoid wasting budget by prioritizing niche-relevant, high-DA sites with organic traffic. Direct outreach often outperforms agencies. Evaluate metrics like traffic authenticity and engagement potential. See essential tips to optimize ROI from guest posting.
Is content collaboration better than paid guest posting?
Yes, collaborating with niche-relevant blogs offers mutual value without violating Google’s policies. Share expertise, data, or unique insights, which often results in organic backlinks. Learn how content collaboration works at scale.
How does Google penalize unethical link-building practices?
Google's SpamBrain identifies patterns of unnatural linking, including paid guest posts. Penalties may reduce rankings and traffic drastically. A better alternative is focusing on natural authority-building. Explore ethical strategies for long-term SEO growth.
Are backlinks the only benefit of guest posting?
No, guest posting also boosts brand visibility, establishes industry authority, and fosters partnerships. However, these benefits rely on providing high-quality, value-driven content. Discover all proven benefits of guest blogging on niche sites.
How can founders scale guest posting without compromising quality?
Founders should use tools like AI-driven outreach and content optimization but ensure every guest post aligns with their brand's goals. Commit to high-quality over high volume. Get insights into scalable content strategies.
Is guest posting still relevant given LinkedIn's rise as a publishing platform?
Guest posting remains relevant for industry-specific audiences unreachable via LinkedIn. Combining blogs and LinkedIn articles enhances visibility in distinct niches. Learn when to choose guest blogging vs. LinkedIn.
What tools can startups use to identify valuable guest posting opportunities?
Startups can use platforms like BuzzStream and Ahrefs to identify genuine high-authority sites that match their niche, filtering out low-performing or spammy domains. Unlock tips to attract high-value guest blogging leads.
Are agencies necessary for startup SEO guest posting?
While agencies can expedite outreach, they often inflate costs and focus on quantity over quality. Direct outreach gives founders greater control over placement and narrative. Explore a no-agency playbook for cost-effective startup growth.
How can bootstrapped founders leverage no-cost guest posting?
Focus on offering genuine expertise and value to niche-specific platforms. Forgo transactional approaches and build long-term relationships for sustainable growth. Learn more about ethical guest posting for startups.
What’s the best strategy for long-term SEO gains through guest blogging?
The key is consistency, aligning with high-traffic, industry-relevant platforms, and offering original, actionable content. Avoid reliance solely on backlinks. Master SEO with AI-driven strategies.
About the Author
Violetta Bonenkamp, also known as MeanCEO, is an experienced startup founder with an impressive educational background including an MBA and four other higher education degrees. She has over 20 years of work experience across multiple countries, including 5 years as a solopreneur and serial entrepreneur. Throughout her startup experience she has applied for multiple startup grants at the EU level, in the Netherlands and Malta, and her startups received quite a few of those. She’s been living, studying and working in many countries around the globe and her extensive multicultural experience has influenced her immensely.
Violetta is a true multiple specialist who has built expertise in Linguistics, Education, Business Management, Blockchain, Entrepreneurship, Intellectual Property, Game Design, AI, SEO, Digital Marketing, cyber security and zero code automations. Her extensive educational journey includes a Master of Arts in Linguistics and Education, an Advanced Master in Linguistics from Belgium (2006-2007), an MBA from Blekinge Institute of Technology in Sweden (2006-2008), and an Erasmus Mundus joint program European Master of Higher Education from universities in Norway, Finland, and Portugal (2009).
She is the founder of Fe/male Switch, a startup game that encourages women to enter STEM fields, and also leads CADChain, and multiple other projects like the Directory of 1,000 Startup Cities with a proprietary MeanCEO Index that ranks cities for female entrepreneurs. Violetta created the “gamepreneurship” methodology, which forms the scientific basis of her startup game. She also builds a lot of SEO tools for startups. Her achievements include being named one of the top 100 women in Europe by EU Startups in 2022 and being nominated for Impact Person of the year at the Dutch Blockchain Week. She is an author with Sifted and a speaker at different Universities. Recently she published a book on Startup Idea Validation the right way: from zero to first customers and beyond, launched a Directory of 1,500+ websites for startups to list themselves in order to gain traction and build backlinks and is building MELA AI to help local restaurants in Malta get more visibility online.
For the past several years Violetta has been living between the Netherlands and Malta, while also regularly traveling to different destinations around the globe, usually due to her entrepreneurial activities. This has led her to start writing about different locations and amenities from the point of view of an entrepreneur. Here’s her recent article about the best hotels in Italy to work from.
